10 Questions PE Fund CFOs Ask About FX Hedge Programs

This article was written by our content partner, Deaglo

Direct answers to the 10 most common questions PE fund CFOs and COOs ask when structuring, documenting, and reporting a currency hedge program — with specific numbers, instrument mechanics, and accounting treatment for Brazil-focused funds.

1. How much does it cost to hedge USD/BRL for a $200M PE fund?

Hedging USD/BRL for a $200M fund typically costs 8–14% per annum in carry, reflecting Brazil’s interest rate differential with the US (historically 8–12 percentage points). For a 12-month NDF at current rates, expect an all-in cost of roughly $16M–$28Mannually — or 200–350 basis points once amortized. Costs compress with shorter tenors and expand during BRL volatility spikes. Broker spreads on NDF notionals of $50M+ are usually 10–20 pips. Most PE CFOs hedge 50–75% of net equity exposure, reducing the effective cost while retaining some upside currency participation.

2. What is the difference between an NDF and a deliverable forward for BRL?

A Non-Deliverable Forward (NDF) settles in USD at maturity based on the USD/BRL fixing rate (PTAX), with no physical exchange of reais. It is the only viable structure for BRL, since Brazil restricts offshore deliverability of its currency. A deliverable forward, used for currencies like EUR or GBP, involves actual exchange of both currencies at settlement. For PE funds holding Brazilian portfolio companies, NDFs are the standard hedging instrument. They carry counterparty credit risk (mark-to-market exposure) and are typically governed by ISDA Master Agreements with scheduled PTAX fixings published by Brazil’s central bank.

3. How do I document a BRL hedge under IFRS 9 (or ASC 815) to qualify for hedge accounting?

To qualify for IFRS 9 hedge accounting, a CFO must:

‍(1) formally designate the hedging relationship at inception with written documentation identifying the hedged item, hedging instrument, risk being hedged, and hedge ratio

(2) demonstrate the hedge meets the 80–125% effectiveness threshold using prospective and retrospective testing

‍(3) establish a risk management objective and strategy consistent with the designation. For USD/BRL NDFs, the hedged item is typically the foreign currency risk on net investment in a Brazilian subsidiary. Ineffectiveness from basis differences (e.g., PTAX vs. spot) flows through OCI. Rebalancing is permitted under IFRS 9 without dedesignation. US-domiciled funds applying US GAAP use ASC 815, which has broadly similar designation and effectiveness testing requirements but distinct rules around shortcut method eligibility and critical terms matching — confirm with your accounting team which standard applies.

4. What hedge ratio should a PE fund use for EM currency exposure?

Most PE funds targeting EM currencies hedge 50–75% of NAV-equivalent equity exposure. A 100% hedge eliminates currency upside and creates cash flow risk if BRL appreciates sharply (requiring margin or variation margin top-ups). A 0% hedge maximizes return volatility. The optimal ratio depends on the fund’s return attribution target, LP investor base currency, and whether currency risk is considered a strategic or incidental exposure. Funds with USD-denominated performance fees often hedge more aggressively to protect carried interest calculations. Quarterly rebalancing of the ratio to track changing portfolio valuations is considered best practice.

5. What counterparties should a PE fund use for BRL NDF hedging?

PE funds should execute BRL NDFs with tier-1 banks active in EM FX: JPMorgan, Citi, Goldman Sachs, Santander Brasil, Ebury, Macquarie, BTG Pactual, and Itaú BBA are the most liquid dealers for USD/BRL. For funds below $500M AUM, it is common to maintain two to three ISDA relationships to ensure competitive pricing and avoid single-counterparty credit concentration. Credit Support Annexes (CSAs) with two-way variation margin posting reduce bilateral credit exposure. Smaller funds may access NDF liquidity through FX prime brokers or aggregators rather than direct ISDA relationships. Execution via a multi-dealer platform (360T, Bloomberg, FXall) improves price discovery.

6. How does BRL volatility affect hedge costs and when should hedges be rolled?

BRL implied volatility (1-month ATM typically 15–25%) directly affects option-based hedges but not the carry cost of NDFs. NDF costs are driven by interest rate differentials, not vol. However, high vol environments widen bid-offer spreads and increase the cost of rolling hedges. NDFs should be rolled 2–5 business days before expiry to avoid settlement risk at PTAX fixing. Rolling during thin liquidity windows (early morning NY, Brazil holidays) increases slippage. Most PE treasuries set rolling schedules quarterly or semi-annually aligned with valuation cycles. Avoid rolling at quarter-end when dealer balance sheets are constrained and spreads widen.

7. What are the accounting entries for a USD/BRL NDF under IFRS 9 (or ASC 815) cash flow hedge?

Under an IFRS 9 cash flow hedge:

‍(1) At inception, the NDF is recorded at fair value (typically zero).

(2) Each reporting period, mark-to-market gains or losses on the effective portion go to OCI (Other Comprehensive Income), not P&L.

‍(3) The ineffective portion is immediately recognized in P&L.

‍(4) When the hedged transaction affects P&L (e.g., dividend repatriation or exit proceeds), the cumulative OCI amount is reclassified to P&L. The time value of the NDF (if material) may be accounted for separately. Ensure PTAX-based NDF fixing is aligned with the functional currency of the hedged subsidiary to minimize basis ineffectiveness. US-domiciled funds using ASC 815 follow largely parallel journal entries but should confirm treatment with the fund’s accounting team, as rules on OCI reclassification triggers and the accounting for excluded components differ from IFRS 9.

8. Can a PE fund use options instead of forwards to hedge BRL exposure?

Yes. USD put / BRL call options provide asymmetric protection — the fund pays a premium upfront (typically 3–8% of notional for 12-month 10-delta puts) and retains upside if BRL strengthens. Options are preferable when the fund has uncertain exit timing or binary outcome risk (e.g., pending M&A). Collars (buying puts, selling calls) reduce premium cost to near-zero while capping upside. Under IFRS 9, only the intrinsic value of the option is designated in the hedging relationship; time value is accounted for separately in OCI and amortized. BRL options are also non-deliverable (called NDOs) and settle at PTAX in the same way as NDFs. Whether margin is required depends on the trade structure and the fund’s CSA setup with the bank; all NDO trades require ISDA documentation.

9. What are the key execution and counterparty risks in a PE fund BRL NDF hedge program, and how are they managed?

Portfolio company valuations use BRL Running a BRL NDF program exposes PE funds to several operational and market risks beyond FX exposure itself.

‍(1) Counterparty credit risk — open NDF positions accumulate mark-to-market exposure with dealer banks; mitigated by executing across 2–3 ISDA counterparties with two-way CSAs and daily variation margin.

‍(2) Roll and liquidity risk — rolling NDFs at quarter-end or around Brazilian holidays increases spread cost by 5–15 pips; avoided by scheduling rolls 2–5 business days before fixing and staggering maturities.

‍(3) Over-hedge / margin call risk — if BRL appreciates materially, losing NDF positions trigger cash variation margin calls, creating liquidity pressure; managed by maintaining a cash reserve equal to 10–15% of hedge notional.

(4) Exit timing mismatch — portfolio company sales may close weeks before or after NDF maturities, leaving an unmatched directional position; managed by maintaining short-dated NDF overlay positions for imminent exits.

‍(5) Operational risk — incorrect PTAX fixing date elections, wrong settlement instructions, or missed confirmation deadlines can cause settlement failure; mitigated by standardized ISDA confirmations, pre-settlement checklists, and independent confirmation matching.

10. What disclosures are required in LP reports for an FX hedge program?

LPs increasingly expect transparent FX hedge disclosure covering:

‍(1) hedge program objectives and policy (% of NAV hedged, permitted instruments, tenor limits)

‍(2) total notional outstanding by currency pair

‍(3) unrealized mark-to-market gain or loss on open positions

‍(4) realized hedge P&L for the period and its contribution to net returns

‍(5) hedge cost drag in basis points on gross IRR

‍(6) counterparty names and credit ratings. Under ILPA guidelines, FX derivatives should be disclosed with the fair value hierarchy classification (typically Level 2). Some funds include a sensitivity table showing NAV impact per 10% BRL move, hedged vs. unhedged.

Join our Treasury Community

Join our Treasury Community

Treasury Masterminds is a community of professionals working in treasury management or those interested in learning more about various topics related to treasury management, including cash management, foreign exchange management, and payments. To register and connect with Treasury professionals, click the button below.

Check our other blogs

This article was written by our partner, Deaglo

How Real-Time FX Risk Monitoring Helps Treasury

Corporate treasury teams have always managed foreign exchange risk. What has changed is the speed at which that risk moves. A single central bank comment, an unexpected inflation print, or a geopolitical headline can shift currency pairs several percentage points within hours. For treasury teams still working from end-of-day or end-of-week exposure reports, that kind of move is often invisible until it has already affected margins, hedges, or cash forecasts.

This is the core problem that real-time monitoring solves. Instead of reconstructing exposure after the fact, treasury teams get a continuously updated view of where FX risk management stands right now.

How Real-Time FX Risk Monitoring Helps Treasury

Corporate treasury teams have always managed foreign exchange risk. What has changed is the speed at which that risk moves. A single central bank comment, an unexpected inflation print, or a geopolitical headline can shift currency pairs several percentage points within hours. For treasury teams still working from end-of-day or end-of-week exposure reports, that kind of move is often invisible until it has already affected margins, hedges, or cash forecasts.

This is the core problem that real-time monitoring solves. Instead of reconstructing exposure after the fact, treasury teams get a continuously updated view of where FX risk management stands right now.

What Is Real-Time FX Risk Monitoring?

Real-time FX risk monitoring is the continuous tracking of a company’s currency exposures, hedge positions, and market rates as conditions change — rather than on a fixed reporting cycle. Instead of pulling data once a day or once a week into a spreadsheet, treasury teams work from a live view that updates as rates move, transactions post, and hedges are executed or expire.

For most corporate treasury functions, this means visibility into:

  • Net exposure by currency pair, entity, and business unit
  • Hedge coverage ratios against forecasted and confirmed cash flows
  • Mark-to-market value of open FX contracts
  • Interest rate risk tied to floating-rate debt, deposits, or cross-currency positions
  • Deviations from policy limits or hedge targets as they occur

Why Foreign Exchange Risk Is Hard to Track Manually

Most mid-market and even large corporate treasuries still lean on spreadsheets to consolidate exposure across subsidiaries, currencies, and business units. This approach breaks down for a few consistent reasons:

Data is fragmented across systems.Exposure data often lives across ERPs, bank portals, and regional finance teams, so building one consolidated view takes time and manual reconciliation.

Snap shots go stale fast. A spreadsheet reflects exposure at the moment it was built. In a volatile session, that picture can be outdated within hours.

Interest rate risk gets treated separately. Many treasury teams manage foreign exchange risk and interest rate risk indifferent processes entirely, even though the two are frequently linked — for example, through cross-currency swaps or foreign-denominated debt.

Errors compound under time pressure. Manual consolidation during a fast-moving market increases the chance that a stale number drives a hedging decision.

How Real-Time Monitoring Changes the Picture During Volatility Spikes

Volatility spikes are exactly when the lag in manual processes becomes most costly. When a currency pair moves sharply, exposure that looked well-hedged in yesterday’s report can shift materially within the same trading session — particularly for companies with large forecasted cash flows or unhedged inter company balances.

Real-timeFX risk management gives treasury teams three practical advantages in these moments:

  1. Faster identification of exposure changes. Rather than waiting for the next reporting cycle, treasury can see which currency pairs or business units are driving new risk as it emerges.
  2. Earlier hedging decisions. With current data, treasury can evaluate whether to adjust hedge ratios, execute new forwards, or hold position — instead of reacting after the exposure has already grown.
  3. Better internal communication. A live, shared view of exposure gives CFOs and treasurers a common reference point during fast-moving conversations, rather than debating whose spreadsheet is most current.

Interest Rate Risk and FX Risk Are Connected

Interest rate risk rarely moves in isolation from foreign exchange risk, especially for companies with foreign-currency debt, cross-currency financing, or interest rate differentials embedded in forward pricing. A shift in rate expectations in one country can move both the currency and the cost of hedging simultaneously.

Treasury teams that monitor FX and interest rate exposure separately often miss this interaction until it shows up in hedge costs or funding expense. Monitoring both in the same real-time view makes it easier to see how a rate move is also reshaping currency risk — and vice versa.

What to Look for in Real-Time Monitoring Capabilities

No tall monitoring tools offer the same depth. Corporate treasury teams evaluating options for stronger FX risk management should look for:

  • Consolidated exposure across entities and currencies in one place, updated continuously rather than on a batch cycle
  • Combined visibility into foreign exchange risk and interest rate risk, since the two are often linked
  • Configurable alerts tied to policy thresholds, so treasury is notified when exposure or hedge ratios move outside approved ranges
  • Scenario and sensitivity views that show how a given volatility spike would affect current positions
  • An audit trail that supports internal reporting and board-level risk discussion

Join our Treasury Community

Join our Treasury Community

Treasury Masterminds is a community of professionals working in treasury management or those interested in learning more about various topics related to treasury management, including cash management, foreign exchange management, and payments. To register and connect with Treasury professionals, click the button below.

This article is from our partner, Ebury

We want our clients to stay on top of current Fraud & Security trends to help keep your money safe; that’s why we’d like to share some tips to avoid scams, guide you through the detection, prevention and recovery stages and on how to comply with the Data Protection Regulation.

Cryptocurrency Scams

Investment scams have always been on our radar, from property investment scams to pyramid schemes, but the new scam of choice for 2021 seems to be cryptocurrency schemes. With cryptocurrency being one of the newer concepts when it comes to investment, fraudsters are provided with an opportunity to exploit this knowledge gap in consumers. These cryptocurrency schemes are convincing, with some even using fake celebrity endorsements. The schemes prompt potential investors to fill in a contact form, which is followed up with a telephone call from the scammer encouraging the investor to set up a cryptocurrency wallet. During this process, the scammer installs remote access software onto the investor’s device. Over time, the victim is encouraged to invest increasingly large amounts until the scammer finally empties the wallet and flees. With these particular scams, the warning signs include the unrealistic promise of big profits or ‘get rich quick’ advertising and the corporate names that these scammers masquerade under will not be registered with the FCA. It is also important to note that a legitimate investment in cryptocurrency would always involve a digital wallet that only the account holder can access – if someone else can directly control it, alarm bells should be raised.

Be Aware: Electronic Goods Scam

We have recently become aware of a successful scam doing the rounds internationally. A scam company called ‘Infinity Electronic’, ‘Infinity Element’ or ‘Ocean Components’ claims to sell electronic goods. It takes payments from international customers to bank accounts in a variety of names, located in Hong Kong. The goods promised are never sent, and by the time the victims realise, the company’s website is down and can no longer be contacted. Should you fall victim to a scam of this kind, we recommend reporting it to local law enforcement or your local fraud reporting agency. If the payment has been processed via Ebury, let us know at fraud@ebury.com.

How to spot APP Fraud

To avoid falling victim to scams, or any form of APP fraud, follow these tips:

New Suppliers

  • Check the web presence of new suppliers – if they have a website, how old is it and is it well maintained?
  • Do a quick Google search of the new supplier’s name to check if there is any nefarious information reported online
  • Search for legitimate online reviews of new suppliers before you commit to a purchase
  • Ask yourself – is the deal this new supplier is offering too good to be true?
  • Are the bank details of the new supplier located in the same country as the supplier?

Existing Suppliers

  • When you receive an email from an existing supplier, make sure it is coming from the same email address you
  • usually communicate with
  • Check incoming emails for signs of email spoofing – fraudsters may set up email addresses that mimic your supplier’s email address
  • If an existing supplier expresses undue urgency for payment or changes their bank details last minute – confirm the request on a trusted telephone number
  • If a supplier’s bank details change to a bank account located in a different country – check if this change is genuine on a trusted telephone number
  • Check payment invoices for signs of alteration or discrepancies in spelling or format

Compromised Email Accounts – Detection, Prevention and Recovery

Securing communication via email has become essential for every organization. Here at Ebury, we take email security very seriously and aim to protect our employees from social engineering techniques such as phishing. Attackers are now favouring simpler phishing attacks harvesting user credentials, as opposed to more sophisticated attacks involving malware. User credentials can allow an attacker access to an email account and, consequently, to sensitive information that the attacker can use to dupe their victims. Be suspicious if you receive emails asking you to verify your account or enter login details. These emails may redirect you to spoofed websites that can capture your credentials. Do not get scared by urgent requests – instead, go directly to the correspondent website and access it from there to verify your account status. We are aware that detection can be challenging. Bigger organisations such as Ebury rely on machine learning engines to detect compromised accounts and quickly activate an incident response plan. For smaller businesses, it is critical to read your emails with care, check the sender, analyse the language used and look out for unusual requests such as a change of bank details for a supplier. To make sure your own account has not been compromised, regularly check for any forwarding rules or email filters in your email settings. Detection is important, but we would also like you to become familiar with some prevention measures that will help to keep your account safe. Always use complex, unique passwords and avoid using the same credentials across different systems, as this will leave you vulnerable to attackers. Always configure multi-factor authentication where available and, if possible, utilise security mechanisms to detect phishing attacks or potentially compromised accounts. If you think your email account has been compromised, please follow these email recovery steps:

  • Change the password on your email account and any account that shares this password
  • Check your email filters and forwarding rules to ensure that no suspicious rules have been created that could be diverting your emails
  • Make sure you verify your sent items. Attackers may have sent fraudulent emails to your contacts
  • Change the Security Questions in the email recovery section of your email account
  • If not already active, enable 2 Factor Authentication on your email account
  • If not already active, enable 2 Factor Authentication on your EBO account
  • Clean up your browser cookies and cache
  • Ensure that your device’s operating system is up to date – any outstanding updates will install the latest security fixes
  • Run anti-virus software on your device. Ideally, there should always be anti-virus software installed and up to date on your device
  • Communicate this incident to your contacts

Tips to help sole traders, small and medium-sized businesses in understanding and assist in complying with their data protection obligations

Ebury is committed to ensuring the security and protection of the personal information we collect and process to provide a consistent and compliant approach to data protection. The key principles we adhere to are;

  • Transparency in the use of personal data;
  • The lawful, fair and necessary processing of personal data ;
  • Ensuring the accuracy of personal data and removing it when no longer necessary;
  • Keeping data safe and secure and protecting the integrity and confidentiality

With this in mind, it is important to acknowledge that cybersecurity and, in turn, implementing good data protection and security practices is everyone’s responsibility. Cyberattacks don’t only happen to large corporations. Small businesses, groups and individuals have to protect their IT systems, too. Being your own boss is great, and there are many rewards; however, there are also many responsibilities in ensuring you protect the information that is important to you. Following these tips is a good starting point in protecting the information you work with;

Tip one: Know what data you have

Even if you don’t think you use or keep a lot of data, you still need to know what personal data you have, so make a quick list of it if you haven’t already.

More Info

Also take into consideration the data you have saved on smartphones, tablets or computers. This could be people’s names and contact details, email addresses or notes that you have made.

Tip two: Keeping personal data? Tell people what you do with it

If you are processing and storing personal information, you need to let people know what you’re doing with their data. The easiest way to do this is to have a privacy notice available, either in a hard copy or on your website (see Ebury’s Privacy Policy (UK))

More Info

People have a right to know what you’re doing with their personal data. Many small business owners use third-party suppliers to provide them with a ready-made privacy notice. If you choose this route over making your own, be aware that you still need to know what it says. Your privacy notice sets out your commitment to the individuals (e.g. customers/clients) who are trusting you with their personal data.

Tip three: Keep it safe

Where you are processing and storing personal data, you have to protect people’s data from getting lost or falling into the wrong hands. Data Security doesn’t have to cost the earth, but any business that wants to be trusted has to get it right. If you are using, storing or processing lots of data, and in particular personal/sensitive data, then you need to take some extra steps to keep it safe.

Practical Steps to keep your IT systems safe and secure:

  1. Backup your data. Create a backup copy of your data, and do this regularly. Store it somewhere other than your main workspace, if possible; Consider the use of a cloud service for electronic data. That way, if there is a break-in, fire or flood, you don’t lose anything.
  2. Use strong passwords. Make sure you, your staff, volunteers, and anyone else involved in your operations use strong passwords – including smartphones, laptops, tablets, email accounts and computers.
  3. Take care when working remotely. If you, or people you work with, do their work remotely, make sure the devices you use are as secure as the equipment you use in the office.
  4. Be wary of suspicious emails. Educate yourself and those working for you on how to spot suspicious emails. Checking for obvious signs such as bad grammar, requests for you to act urgently, and payment requests will help you avoid being caught out. If it looks suspicious, don’t trust it – and warn your staff not to either.
  5. Install anti-virus and malware protection. And keep it up to date
  6. Don’t leave paperwork or laptops unattended. Data breaches can occur when staff and volunteers leave paperwork or laptops unattended. This could be in the boot of a car, on a train, or at home. Make sure you take steps to protect the personal data you hold by being vigilant and storing it securely away when not in use.
  7. Making sure your Wi-Fi is secure. Using public Wi-Fi or an insecure connection could put your valuable information at risk, so you should make sure you always use a secure connection when connecting to the internet.
  8. Lock your screen when you’re away from your desk. And make sure those working with you do the same. Taking steps to lock your screen when you leave your desk is a simple thing to do, but it will prevent someone else from accessing your computer.
  9. Keep on top of who has access to what. You should consider and apply restrictions on who has access to your IT systems and buildings. Think about the principle of ‘need-to-know ’; the fewer people with access, the better. Make sure you limit IT access to people who work for you, where possible. If someone leaves your company, or if they’re absent for long periods of time, you may want to consider suspending their access to your systems.
  10. Don’t keep data for longer than you need it. Staying on top of what personal data you hold will save you time and resources. It will also help you with your data protection responsibilities. Only keep what you need, for as long as you need it.
  11. Dispose of old IT equipment and records securely. Before you get rid of them, make sure no personal data or anything sensitive and important to your business is left on personal computers, laptops, smartphones or any other devices. You could consider using deletion software, or hire a specialist to wipe the data.

Some other simple security controls could include:

  • Making sure all potential entry points (doors/windows) have locks and are working;
  • Never leave anything unattended in vehicles;
  • Separating your business email account from your personal email account, rather than using the same one; and
  • Being extra vigilant when sending or receiving emails – to help prevent sophisticated phishing attempts and scams.

Information Commissioner’s Office [Data Protection when it’s just you]

Also Read

Join our Treasury Community

Treasury Masterminds is a community of professionals working in treasury management or those interested in learning more about various topics related to treasury management, including cash management, foreign exchange management, and payments. To register and connect with Treasury professionals, click the button below.

This article is a contribution from our partner, Avollone

Agentic AI in KYC: Costs, ROI and Compliance Risks

Artificial intelligence is transforming how organizations manage Know Your Customer (KYC), Customer Due Diligence (CDD), sanctions screening and financial crime investigations. AI agents can review documents, extract information, prepare questionnaires and support risk assessments. For compliance teams dealing with growing workloads, the opportunity to reduce repetitive manual work is significant.

But as organizations move from experimenting with AI to relying on it for daily operations, another question is emerging: What happens when the cost of AI increases?

As Stacia Garr explores in her Harvard Business Review article, How to Respond to the Coming AI Cost Shock, the economics of enterprise AI are changing. For financial crime compliance teams, understanding those economics is becoming an important part of building sustainable AI-powered operations.

What Is Agentic AI in KYC and Financial Crime Compliance?

Agentic AI refers to artificial intelligence systems that can plan and execute multiple tasks toward a defined objective, using tools, information and predefined permissions. In KYC and financial crime compliance, AI agents can support document collection, information extraction, questionnaire completion, sanctions investigations and due diligence reviews. Unlike traditional automation, which follows fixed instructions, agentic systems can coordinate several steps within a workflow. However, their activities still require appropriate controls, validation and human oversight.

Why Could Agentic AI Become More Expensive?

Most organizations evaluate AI investments based on expected efficiency gains. If an AI system reduces the time required to complete a KYC request from an hour to 15 minutes, the potential productivity benefit is relatively easy to understand. But the cost of delivering that automation can be harder to predict.

Many AI services charge based on tokens, which represent units of information processed by a model. Costs can depend on the model used, the volume of information processed, the number of interactions and the complexity of the workflow. In her HBR article, Garr argues that enterprise AI adoption has benefited from software vendors absorbing substantial infrastructure and processing costs, creating expectations around inexpensive or included AI functionality. She warns:

“The era of artificial pricing is coming to an end.”

As vendors introduce or expand usage-based pricing, organizations may find that AI processing becomes a more significant variable operating expense. This is particularly relevant for financial crime compliance, where workload complexity can vary considerably. An AI agent handling a straightforward corporate KYC questionnaire may require relatively little processing. Another investigating a multinational ownership structure could need to examine hundreds of documents, identify connected entities and perform multiple rounds of analysis. The second workflow may consume substantially more computing resources.

How Do Token Costs Affect KYC Automation?

Token consumption is an important cost driver for many AI-powered compliance workflows. Consider two hypothetical KYC cases: The first involves a domestic company with a straightforward ownership structure, a small number of directors and readily available corporate documents. The second involves an international corporate group with multiple subsidiaries, complex beneficial ownership, documents in several languages and additional due diligence requirements.

Even if both cases are classified as KYC reviews, their AI processing requirements may be very different.

Agentic systems can also perform repeated reasoning steps, retrieve information and reprocess documents as they work toward completing a task.

Risk consultant Pedro Arevalo – who has deep expertise in risk, financial crime and fraud, including the application of AI, advanced analytics and technology to strengthen controls, improve decision-making and transform customer and operational processes – highlights this concern in his LinkedIn commentary on the potential AI cost shock for financial crime compliance operations, observing that documents, connected parties, ownership layers and transactions can materially increase token consumption. This creates a potential mismatch between the number of KYC cases completed and the computing resources required. For organizations planning AI adoption, measuring the average cost per completed case is therefore more useful than looking only at the price per million tokens.

How Should Compliance Teams Measure AI Return on Investment?

The return on investment from AI in KYC should reflect the full cost of completing a compliance process. This includes AI processing costs, software fees, implementation, human review, quality assurance and exception handling.

A practical approach is to compare the total cost of an AI-assisted workflow with the cost of completing the same work manually, while maintaining comparable quality and control standards. For example, an organization could assess how much time AI saves when preparing KYC responses, how often human reviewers need to correct its work and how frequently cases require additional investigation. As Garr explains:

“The key pricing elements are out of your control.”

Her point refers to the uncertainty surrounding interactions per agent, usage per request and unit pricing.

For compliance leaders, this implys that understanding AI return on investment requires monitoring both processing costs and the operational value delivered. The objective isn’t simply to maximize automation. There’s also a need to reduce the cost and effort of completing KYC accurately, with consistency and within acceptable risk parameters.

Why Is Human Oversight Still Essential in AI-Powered KYC?

AI can prepare information, identify inconsistencies and recommend next steps. But organizations still need people who understand the regulatory context and can exercise professional judgment. This becomes particularly important when cases involve complex ownership structures, sanctions exposure, politically exposed persons or enhanced due diligence.

There is also an operational resilience consideration. If an organization becomes heavily dependent on AI and subsequently faces a major price increase, provider outage or service disruption, it needs a practical way to maintain essential compliance operations. Garr highlights the risks of losing institutional knowledge when organizations replace employees with AI-driven processes. And Pedro Arevalo raises the same concern specifically for financial crime compliance, asking:

“If AI becomes too expensive, can humans absorb the work?”

This is a particularly relevant question for compliance teams, where experienced professionals may need years to develop expertise in financial crime risk assessment and investigations. Organizations should therefore retain sufficient internal expertise, document procedures and establish contingency arrangements. The most resilient model would combine AI efficiency with human accountability.

Can Different AI Models Help Control KYC Costs?

Many have pointed out that not every task requires the most advanced or expensive AI model, and this is certainly true for compliance. Extracting information from a standardized document, identifying missing questionnaire fields and preparing a simple summary may require different capabilities from analyzing complex ownership structures or evaluating ambiguous adverse media findings. So, organizations can potentially reduce costs by matching the model to the task. For example, simpler models may handle routine extraction and classification, while more capable models are reserved for complex analysis. Some organizations may also consider open-weight models for suitable tasks, although infrastructure, maintenance, security and validation costs still need to be included. Arevalo makes a similar recommendation, encouraging organizations to balance commercial and open models rather than relying on the most expensive LLM for every compliance task.

Some have considered the usage of lower-cost models. However, it needs to be weighed against their ability to meet the necessary standards for accuracy, reliability and data protection. Models that do not will fail at meeting both the economic and data requirements, causing more work and risk.

How Can Organizations Make Agentic AI Costs More Predictable?

Predictability starts with understanding how AI is actually being used. Compliance teams should establish baseline processing costs for common workflows, including KYC questionnaire completion, document extraction, ownership analysis and screening investigations. They should also monitor how costs change with case complexity and volume.

Vendor arrangements matter as well. Organizations should understand how usage is priced, whether there are consumption limits, how price changes are handled and what happens when demand exceeds forecasts.

Garr recommends incorporating AI consumption into broader organizational planning rather than treating it solely as a technology expense. Arevalo extends this argument to financial crime compliance, recommending that organizations:

“Plan capacity and budgets around headcount AND tokens.”

This recognizes that AI is becoming an operational resource alongside human expertise.

Organizations should also distinguish between purchasing AI infrastructure directly and using software that incorporates AI into its services. Customers may not be billed per token, but underlying AI economics can still influence pricing and service delivery.

What Does Sustainable AI-Powered KYC Look Like?

Sustainable AI adoption requires a balance between automation, cost control, governance and operational resilience. For KYC teams, one effective approach is to apply AI where it can eliminate repetitive administrative work while preserving human review for decisions that require judgment, and this is particularly relevant to information collection and KYC response management.

Fintech / Regtech saas software providers such as Avallone have AI-powered KYC capabilities uniquely designed to support activities such as preparing KYC responses, reusing previously validated information and coordinating tasks across the response process. For example, Avallone’s KYC Responder lets organizations reduce the effort involved in repeatedly answering similar requests from banks and other counterparties, and their KYC Collector supports structured information gathering, document management, screening and risk assessment workflows.

Centralizing information and reusing validated data can also reduce unnecessary duplication, although actual AI cost savings depend on system design and usage.

Balancing AI Efficiency with Economic Sustainability

There is no argument that agentic AI has considerable potential to improve KYC and financial crime compliance operations. But automation should not be measured solely by how many tasks an AI agent can complete or how much employee time it saves.

Organizations also need to understand processing costs, changing usage patterns, human oversight requirements and the financial implications of scaling AI across their operations.

The next stage of AI adoption in compliance will require organizations to think about capacity in two dimensions: people and computing resources so that KYC operations that remain efficient, reliable and financially sustainable as AI becomes part of everyday work.


Sources:

Stacia Garr, Harvard Business Review, “How to Respond to the Coming AI Cost Shock,” August 17, 2026. https://hbr.org/2026/08/how-to-respond-to-the-coming-ai-cost-shock

Pedro Arevalo, LinkedIn commentary on the potential AI cost shock for financial crime compliance operations, October 13, 2026. https://lnkd.in/p/etXbM6n2

OpenAI, “What Are Tokens and How to Count Them?” https://help.openai.com/en/articles/4936856-what-are-tokens-and-how-to-count-them

Have more KYC questions?

Avallone is here for you. Connect with one of our KYC professionals who can address your questions, concerns and needs.

Also Read

Join our Treasury Community

Treasury Masterminds is a community of professionals working in treasury management or those interested in learning more about various topics related to treasury management, including cash management, foreign exchange management, and payments. To register and connect with Treasury professionals, click the button below.